What are the real business risks associated with ESG?
Each component of ESG potentially exposes banks to a specific set of business risks. These ESG risks can be organized into three basic categories:
Reputational risks
When a bank begins implementing changes in strategy and reporting to address ESG issues, it encounters reputational risk related to the information it discloses publicly. ESG-related disclosures must be supported, validated, and reported clearly, accurately, and consistently with a bank’s mission and strategy. The rise in environmentally and socially conscious investors, customers, and employees and the evolving regulatory landscape mean greater scrutiny of the validity of ESG-disclosed information.
Transition risks
Transition risks in the environmental realm include the costs a bank could incur in shifting to a lower carbon or carbon-neutral operating model, which requires changes in policies, procedures, and processes. The social aspects of ESG also entail transition risks as banks restructure their lending strategies and credit policies to improve service levels to traditionally underserved communities. Diversity-driven changes in hiring, promotion, and other personnel practices can generate additional transition risks. Substantial transition risks are also associated with the governance component of ESG, which involves compliance with rapidly changing regulatory regimens covering a broad range of issues.
Physical risks
In terms of physical risk, banks should recognize and evaluate steps to mitigate climate change-related risks to their own facilities and to customer property or other physical assets that have been used to secure loans.